Skip to content

Republish as a REC -> CR #180

Open
@marcoscaceres

Description

@marcoscaceres

To-Do List for Last Call for Review of Proposed Amendments

  • (1) Plan the Last Call for Review of Proposed Amendments

    • Decide on the announcement date.
    • Set a minimum 60-day review period.
  • (2) Prepare the Last Call Announcement

    • Clearly state whether this is a Last Call for:
      • Proposed Corrections
      • Proposed Additions
      • Proposed Corrections and Additions
    • List the specific candidate amendments under review.
    • Include the exact review comment deadline (≥ 60 days from announcement).
    • Request review and implementation experience if not already provided.
  • (3) Distribute the Announcement

    • Send to relevant W3C groups.
    • Send to the public (appropriate W3C public channels).
    • Notify the Advisory Committee (AC).
  • (4) Open Patent Exclusion Opportunity

    • Mark the combined draft (existing Recommendation + amendments) as a Patent Review Draft.
    • Start the patent exclusion period as per Patent Policy.
  • (5) Collect and Track Comments

    • Set up a public record/issue tracker for incoming comments.
    • Acknowledge and log each review comment received.
  • (6) Assess Implementation Experience

    • Gather and document existing implementations, tests, or prototypes exercising the proposed amendments.
  • (7) End of Review Period Actions

    • After the review deadline, compile all comments.
    • Coordinate with W3C to determine the next step:
      • Accept as-is
      • Reject
      • Return to Working Group for comment resolution
  • (8) Address Feedback if Required

    • If changes are requested, revise the proposed amendments.
    • Issue another Last Call for Review if there are substantive changes.
  • (9) Confirm Requirements Met

    • Ensure all comments are addressed.
    • Verify adequate implementation experience.
    • Confirm all Recommendation requirements are fulfilled.
  • (10) Update the Recommendation

    • Once approved, request publication of the updated Recommendation.
  • (11) Handle Postponed Amendments (if any)

    • Re-include any postponed amendments in a future Last Call.
  • (12) Maintain Regular Review Cadence

    • Ensure that Last Calls are not issued more frequently than roughly every 6 months.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions