%PDF-1.2 3 0 obj > stream 1 0 0 1 194.57 743.64 cm BT /F104 17.93 Tf 0 0 Td[(A)-250(Half)-250(Century)-251(of)-250(Re)15(viewing)]TJ/F105 15.94 Tf 63.18 -28.89 Td[(D.)-250(H.)-250(Lehmer*)]TJ/F106 13.95 Tf -197.84 -40.85 Td[(In)-269(going)-268(o)15(v)15(er)-269(in)-268(my)-269(mind)-269(the)-268(more)-269(than)-268(65)-269(years)-268(that)-269(I)-269(ha)20(v)16(e)-269(de)25(v)20(oted)-269(to)-268(mathematics)-268(the)-269(ac-)]TJ -23.91 -16.93 Td[(ti)25(vity)-290(that)-291(I)-290(ha)20(v)15(e)-291(sustained)-290(the)-291(longest,)-304(besides)-290(research,)-304(is)-290(that)-291(of)-290(a)-291(re)25(vie)25(wers)-290(for)-291(Mathematical)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(Re)25(vie)25(ws)-211(\050hereafter)-212(referred)-211(as)-212(MR\051.)-228(I)-212(plan)-212(to)-211(gi)25(v)15(e)-212(some)-212(account)-211(of)-212(this)-212(acti)25(vity)-212(because)-211(re)25(vie)25(wing)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(of)-236(research)-235(papers)-235(ne)25(v)15(er)-235(gets)-235(the)-236(attention)-235(it)-236(deserv)16(es)-236(in)-235(the)-236(literature.)]TJ 23.91 -16.93 Td[(The)-293(circumstances)-291(surrounding)-292(my)-293(becoming)-292(a)-293(re)25(vie)26(wer)-293(for)-292(MR)-293(were)-292(a)-293(little)-292(peculiar)55(.)-407(The)]TJ -23.91 -16.94 Td[(year)-273(w)10(as)-273(1938)-274(and)-273(I)-273(w)10(as)-273(in)-274(Cambridge,)-282(England.)-348(I)-274(had)-273(been)-273(writing)-273(re)25(vie)25(ws)-273(for)-273(Zentralblatt)-273(f)]TJ 529.54 0.07 Td[(¨)]TJ -1.16 -0.07 Td[(ur)]TJ -528.38 -16.94 Td[(Matematik.)-479(I)-316(be)15(gan)-312(hearing)-316(of)-317(the)-317(e)15(xpulsion)-316(of)-317(the)-317(Je)25(wish)-316(re)25(vie)25(wers)-316(of)-317(the)-317(Zentralblatt)-316(and)-317(of)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(the)-260(resignation)-259(in)-259(protest)-260(of)-259(some)-260(of)-259(the)-260(re)25(vie)26(wers)-260(in)-260(England)-259(and)-259(in)-260(the)-260(United)-259(States.)-307(I)-260(quickly)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(resigned)-214(from)-214(the)-215(Zentralblatt.)-227(Then)-215(came)-214(the)-214(ne)25(ws)-215(that)-214(a)-214(re)25(vie)25(w)-215(journal)-214(w)10(as)-214(being)-214(planned)-214(in)-215(the)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(United)-235(States)-235(and)-236(I)-235(w)10(as)-236(ask)10(ed)-235(to)-236(re)25(vie)26(w)-236(for)-235(it.)]TJ 23.91 -16.94 Td[(My)-237(rst)-237(re)25(vie)25(w)-237(for)-237(MR)-237(appeared)-237(on)-237(pages)-237(38–39)-237(of)-237(v)20(ol.)-237(1)-237(\0501940\051)-237(as)-237(a)-237(discussion)-237(of)-237(the)-237(book)]TJ/F107 13.95 Tf -23.91 -16.94 Td[(Elementary)-308(number)-308(theory)]TJ/F106 13.95 Tf 154.94 0 Td[(by)-270(Uspensk)15(y)-270(and)-271(Heaslet.)-340(I)-270(mailed)-271(a)-270(re)25(vie)25(w)-270(of)-271(a)-271(paper)-270(on)-270(numerical)]TJ -154.94 -16.93 Td[(functions)-232(to)-232(MR)-232(yesterday)65(.)-234(This)-232(mak)10(es)-232(48)-233(years)-232(of)-232(re)25(vie)25(wing.)-234(I)-232(think)-232(that)-232(must)-232(be)-233(something)-231(of)-233(a)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(record.)]TJ 23.91 -16.94 Td[(Ov)15(er)-321(all)-321(these)-321(years)-321(I)-321(ha)20(v)16(e)-322(seen)-320(little)-321(change)-321(in)-321(the)-321(actual)-321(job)-321(of)-321(re)25(vie)25(wing,)-342(in)-321(spite)-321(of)-321(the)]TJ -23.91 -16.93 Td[(substantial)-247(increase)-248(in)-248(the)-248(number)-247(of)-248(books)-248(and)-248(papers)-248(re)26(vie)25(wed)-248(each)-248(year)-248(and)-248(the)-247(great)-248(increase)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(in)-314(the)-314(comple)15(xity)-314(of)-314(the)-314(classication)-314(of)-314(the)-314(subject)-314(matter)56(.)-472(This)-314(is)-314(no)-314(doubt)-314(due)-314(to)-315(part)-314(to)-314(the)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(e)15(xcellent)-301(administrati)26(v)15(e)-301(staf)25(f.)-432(Ne)25(w)-301(v)20(olunteers)-301(are)-301(added)-301(to)-301(the)-302(re)26(vie)25(wing)-301(staf)25(f)-301(as)-301(needed.)-433(I)-301(can)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(only)-235(imagine)-235(the)-236(problems)-235(that)-235(beset)-236(the)-235(cro)25(wd)-235(in)-236(Ann)-235(Arbor)55(.)-235(F)15(or)-236(that)-235(I)-236(am)-235(thankful.)]TJ 23.91 -16.94 Td[(At)-198(one)-198(time)-198(I)-198(v)21(olunteered)-198(to)-198(be)-198(on)-198(a)-198(small)-197(panel)-198(of)-198(re)25(vie)25(wers)-197(who)-198(w)10(ould)-198(accept)-197(papers)-198(written)]TJ -23.91 -16.94 Td[(in)-245(an)-244(obscure)-244(language.)-262(It)-245(surprised)-244(me)-244(ho)25(w)-244(easy)-245(it)-244(w)10(as)-245(to)-244(read)-244(a)-245(paper)-244(or)-245(book)-244(without)-244(kno)25(wing)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(the)-193(alphabet)-193(or)-194(the)-193(grammar)-193(of)-194(the)-193(language.)-221(This)-193(is)-194(because)-193(the)-193(author)-194(adopted)-193(the)-193(uni)25(v)15(ersally)-193(ac-)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(cepted)-166(mathematical)-165(notation)-166(established)-165(by)-166(Euler)55(.)-212(I)-166(can)-166(recall)-166(re)25(vie)25(wing)-165(a)-167(book)-165(written)-166(in)-166(T)45(urkish,)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(I)-196(think,)-203(whose)-195(title)-196(consisted)-195(of)-196(tw)11(o)-196(w)10(ords.)-222(My)-196(wife)-195(accuses)-195(me)-196(of)-195(not)-196(learning)-195(which)-196(w)11(ord)-196(means)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(“number”)-235(and)-235(which)-236(means)-235(“theory”.)-235(Ne)25(v)15(ertheless,)-235(the)-235(book)-235(w)10(as)-236(well)-235(written.)]TJ 23.91 -16.94 Td[(The)-304(obscure)-304(language)-304(panel)-304(w)10(as)-304(abandoned)-304(once)-304(the)-304(re)25(vie)25(wing)-304(staf)25(f)-304(became)-304(more)-304(interna-)]TJ -23.91 -16.93 Td[(tional.)-306(W)80(e)-259(used)-259(to)-259(see)-259(quite)-259(a)-259(lot)-259(of)-259(re)25(vie)25(ws)-259(written)-259(in)-259(French)-259(and)-259(German)-258(and)-259(less)-259(frequently)-259(in)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(Italian.)-266(No)25(w)-246(there)-246(is)-245(an)-246(“only)-246(in)-246(English”)-245(polic)15(y)-246(for)-246(re)25(vie)26(ws.)-267(While)-245(English)-246(is)-246(becoming)-245(the)-246(pre-)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(ferred)-249(language)-248(of)-249(science)-249(these)-248(days,)-253(this)-248(polic)15(y)-249(is)-249(detracting)-248(from)-249(the)-249(international)-248(character)-249(of)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(MR.)]TJ 23.91 -16.94 Td[(Another)-241(peculiarity)-240(of)-242(the)-241(re)25(vie)26(wer')55(s)-241(w)10(ork)-241(is)-241(the)-242(tendenc)16(y)-241(of)-242(MR)-241(to)-241(assign)-241(a)-241(paper)-241(by)-241(author)]TJ -23.91 -16.94 Td[(A)-275(to)-275(re)25(vie)26(wer)-275(R,)-275(who)-275(recently)-274(re)25(vie)25(wed)-275(a)-275(pre)26(vious)-275(paper)-275(by)-274(A.)-354(This)-275(is)-275(natural.)-353(Ho)25(we)26(v)15(er)40(,)-285(this)-275(is)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(sometimes)-240(hard)-241(on)-241(the)-241(re)25(vie)26(wer)-241(who)-241(thus)-241(becomes)-240(an)-241(unwilling)-240(e)15(xpert)-241(on)-241(a)-241(tin)15(y)-241(subject)-240(of)-241(math-)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(ematics.)]TJ ET -158.57 -634.19 144 0.4 re f 1 0 0 1 -158.57 -644.96 cm BT /F108 11.96 Tf 0 0 Td[(*Reprinted)-313(from)]TJ/F109 11.96 Tf 83.89 0 Td[(A)-315(century)-313(of)-314(mathematics)-313(in)-314(America,)-330(P)81(art)-315(I)]TJ/F108 11.96 Tf 216.5 0 Td[(,)-315(pp.)-314(265-266,)-329(American)-313(Math.)-314(Soc.,)-330(Pro)15(vidence,)]TJ -300.39 -16.94 Td[(RI,)-249(1988)]TJ ET endstream endobj 4 0 obj 7070 endobj 1 0 obj > /ProcSet [/PDF /Text] >> endobj 2 0 obj > endobj 11 0 obj > stream 1 0 0 1 59.91 746.03 cm BT /F106 13.95 Tf 0 0 Td[(Other)-296(problems)-296(with)-296(writing)-296(a)-296(re)25(vie)25(w)-296(arise)-296(when)-296(the)-296(author)-296(is)-297(not)-296(conforming)-296(to)-296(the)-296(“terse)]TJ -23.91 -16.93 Td[(and)-196(unmoti)25(v)25(ated)-196(nomenclature)-196(and)-196(notation”)-196(of)-196(the)-196(professional)-196(mathematician.)-222(This)-196(is)-196(especially)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(true)-199(if)-198(the)-199(subject)-198(is)-199(Number)-198(Theory)65(,)-206(where)-198(so)-199(man)16(y)-199(of)-199(the)-198(contrib)20(utions)-198(are)-199(from)-198(amateurs.)-223(These)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(authors)-245(feel)-246(compelled)-246(to)-245(write)-246(about)-246(the)-245(details)-246(of)-246(their)-246(personal)-245(disco)15(v)15(eries)-245(and)-246(methods,)-248(when)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(a)-237(little)-237(reading)-236(w)10(ould)-237(ha)20(v)16(e)-237(disclosed)-237(that)-236(their)-237(disco)15(v)15(eries)-236(were)-237(merely)-237(redisco)16(v)15(eries.)-239(It)-237(is)-237(al)10(w)10(ays)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(depressing)-304(to)-305(write)-304(a)-305(re)25(vie)25(w)-304(of)-305(such)-305(a)-304(w)10(ork.)-443(One)-305(can)-304(dismiss)-304(the)-305(author')55(s)-304(w)10(ork)-305(with)-304(“a)-305(partial)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(redisco)16(v)15(ery)-282(of)-282(a)-282(theorem)-282(of)-282(Gauss”.)-374(But)-282(on)-282(the)-282(other)-281(hand)-282(there)-282(is)-282(an)-282(amateur)-281(with)-282(ideas)-282(to)-282(en-)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(courage.)]TJ 23.91 -16.94 Td[(V)111(ery)-199(occasionally)-199(the)-199(author)-199(is)-200(so)-199(upset)-199(by)-199(an)-200(unfriendly)-198(re)25(vie)25(wer)-199(that)-200(he)-199(writes)-199(a)-199(letter)-200(to)-199(MR)]TJ -23.91 -16.93 Td[(demanding)-208(the)-208(ring)-207(of)-209(the)-208(re)25(vie)26(wer)-208(as)-209(an)-208(incompetent)-207(ass.)-226(He)-208(imagines)-208(that)-208(the)-208(re)25(vie)25(wer)-208(is)-208(being)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(paid)-186(for)-186(his)-187(w)11(ork.)-219(If)-187(is)-186(no)25(w)-186(that)-186(the)-186(e)15(x)15(ecuti)25(v)15(e)-186(editor)-186(comes)-186(to)-186(the)-187(rescue)-186(of)-186(the)-186(re)25(vie)25(wer)-186(and)-186(assures)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(the)-235(author)-236(that)-235(the)-236(re)26(vie)25(wer)-236(is)-235(w)10(orking)-235(for)-236(the)-235(mathematical)-235(community)-235(and)-235(not)-236(for)-235(the)-236(author)56(.)]TJ 23.91 -16.93 Td[(A)-181(recent)-182(number)-181(of)-181(the)-182(Notices)-181(has)-181(a)-182(column)-181(on)-181(MR)-181(in)-182(which)-181(it)-182(tells)-181(of)-181(the)-182(problems)-181(of)-181(admin-)]TJ -23.91 -16.94 Td[(istrating)-261(the)-262(publication)-261(and)-262(the)-262(application)-261(of)-262(high)-262(technology)-261(that)-261(we)-262(may)-262(e)15(xpect)-261(in)-262(the)-262(future.)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(As)-247(f)10(ascinating)-247(as)-247(this)-247(information)-246(is,)-250(it)-248(gi)26(v)15(es)-247(no)-248(substitute)-246(for)-247(preparing)-247(an)-247(honest)-247(re)25(vie)25(w)-247(of)-247(each)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(paper)-257(or)-257(book.)-299(A)-257(recently)-256(suggested)-257(substitute)-256(has)-257(been)-257(a)-257(re)26(vie)25(w)-257(of)-257(the)-257(paper)-257(by)-256(the)-257(author)-257(him-)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(self.)-388(This)-287(self-re)26(vie)25(w)-287(w)10(ould)-286(be)-286(submitted)-286(by)-287(the)-286(author)-287(to)-286(MR)-287(at)-286(the)-287(time)-286(the)-286(paper)-287(is)-286(accepted)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(for)-265(publication,)-271(thus)-265(sa)20(ving)-265(months)-264(of)-265(time.)-324(A)-265(fe)25(w)-265(re)25(vie)26(ws)-265(of)-265(this)-265(kind)-265(ha)20(v)15(e)-265(appeared)-264(in)-265(MR)-265(al-)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(ready)65(.)-395(An)15(y)-289(lar)18(ge)-288(scale)-289(adoption)-288(of)-289(this)-289(polic)16(y)-289(w)10(ould)-289(result)-288(in)-289(the)-289(do)25(wngrading)-288(of)-289(the)-288(quality)-289(of)]TJ 0 -16.94 Td[(MR.)-223(Ev)16(en)-197(replacing)-197(an)-197(honest)-197(re)25(vie)26(w)-198(by)-197(an)-197(author')56(s)-197(abstract)-197(of)-197(the)-197(paper)-197(cheapens)-196(the)-197(publication)]TJ 0 -16.93 Td[(some)25(what.)]TJ ET endstream endobj 12 0 obj 4095 endobj 9 0 obj > /ProcSet [/PDF /Text] >> endobj 10 0 obj > endobj 13 0 obj > endobj 7 0 obj > endobj 6 0 obj > endobj 5 0 obj > endobj 8 0 obj > endobj 14 0 obj > endobj 15 0 obj > endobj xref 0 16 0000000000 65535 f 0000007151 00000 n 0000007278 00000 n 0000000009 00000 n 0000007131 00000 n 0000013692 00000 n 0000013603 00000 n 0000013513 00000 n 0000013780 00000 n 0000011552 00000 n 0000011619 00000 n 0000007382 00000 n 0000011531 00000 n 0000011725 00000 n 0000013844 00000 n 0000013894 00000 n trailer > startxref 13989 %%EOF